Help - Search - Members - Calendar - Pictures - Music - Videos
Full Version: Black Or Death?
The Tomb > Vile Pleasures > The Pit Of Zombies
Dan
Ok, labels really don't mean much to me but what is the difference between black metal and death metal? Is Cc death? How about Nile?
Souless
well i will give ya the fastest easiest break down of that question i can my friend...

DEATH METAL=GOOD
BLACK METAL=SHIT

not much more info then that needed lol.gif

smile.gif
vomitor
There is a big difference between Black and Death metal(how about the whole attitude)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!You should find out the difference yourself or do you really want to tell me you dont know that!!!!! blink.gif
Is CC death??Well,i have heard that some people label them as Gore Metal,but yeah basically they are Death Metal band as well as Nile.Actually i dont really understand what did you wanted tell when posting topic like thet,please enlighten me,will you ermm.gif
vomitor
QUOTE (Souless+Nov 12 2005, 04:10 PM)
well i will give ya the fastest easiest break down of that question i can my friend...

DEATH METAL=GOOD
BLACK METAL=SHIT

not much more info then that needed lol.gif

smile.gif
actually i like one black band 1349!!!Why?Because they have way more technical approach to the black metal also they dont have that shitty procuction going on,but that is my opininon anyway wink.gif
Dan
QUOTE (vomitor+Nov 12 2005, 04:17 PM)
There is a big difference between Black and Death metal(how about the whole attitude)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!You should find out the difference yourself or do you really want to tell me you dont know that!!!!! blink.gif
Is CC death??Well,i have heard that some people label them as Gore Metal,but yeah basically they are Death Metal band as well as Nile.Actually i dont really understand what did you wanted tell when posting topic like thet,please enlighten me,will you ermm.gif
Dude, use punctuation marks more often! Anyway, just trying to get a better perspective on this whole death/black metal thing. As i said, labels don't REALLY matter to me, but saying that Cc and Nile are of the same genre is kind of hard to believe. They sound very different to me! I looked around the net and basically if a bant is satanistic i.e Deicide or Dimmu Burgir, then they are black, if they aren't satanists, i.e Cc (hopefully), then they are death! What do you think of that?
Souless
glen benton said even way way way back in the day he always considered themself more black then death metal but for sum reason to the majority they are considered death metal.

...i mean play a cradle of filth song or sum shit then listen to a death metal song...i.e suffocation/cannibal and u will hear the difference.

you wont hear a chorus of gay ass keyboards and harps and gay shit in most any self respecting death metal song.lol
vomitor
QUOTE (Dan+Nov 12 2005, 04:28 PM)
QUOTE (vomitor+Nov 12 2005, 04:17 PM)
There is a big difference between Black and Death metal(how about the whole attitude)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!You should find out the difference yourself or do you  really want to tell me you dont know that!!!!! blink.gif
Is CC death??Well,i have heard that some people label them as Gore Metal,but yeah basically they are Death Metal band as well as Nile.Actually i dont really understand what did you wanted tell when posting topic like thet,please enlighten me,will you ermm.gif

Dude, use punctuation marks more often! Anyway, just trying to get a better perspective on this whole death/black metal thing. As i said, labels don't REALLY matter to me, but saying that Cc and Nile are of the same genre is kind of hard to believe. They sound very different to me! I looked around the net and basically if a bant is satanistic i.e Deicide or Dimmu Burgir, then they are black, if they aren't satanists, i.e Cc (hopefully), then they are death! What do you think of that?
i think that is probably related with sound and the whole attitude as i said before!Of course Deicide's subject obviously has been related with satanic subjects,but their music(sound) is realy pure death metal for me.And for example all black bands dont deal with that satanism shit at all like some bands sing about philosophy,spiritualism but yet majority of them worship satan!
and that punctuation thing lol.gif you are probably right but what can i do about it
silly habit maybe whistling.gif
Souless
how bout he uses sum punctuation marks sumtimes and you learn to spell the word BAND....and we will call it a done deal.lol
vomitor
lol.gif
Souless
and i dunno where the fuk dan came up with use more punctuation at.......u got the shit all over ur post.lol if anything he shoulda said use less of it.lmao
Dan
QUOTE (Souless+Nov 12 2005, 05:17 PM)
and i dunno where the fuk dan came up with use more punctuation at.......u got the shit all over ur post.lol if anything he shoulda said use less of it.lmao
Ok, let's put the punctuation thing behind us and focus on the fact that no one here really knows the difference between black and death. Only goes to show you that labels are REALLY CRAP!!!!!!
Souless
dan my friend..u are a asshat.....lol

how bout we put you behind us..lol and forget u even posted smile.gif lol.gif
Mutilated1
be nice Dave

Dan, we know the difference between Black and Death metal, and if you use the search feature you'd see we've discussed and argued about the difference so much over the past three years most of us are just sick of explaining it to people.

Especially someone who just wants to come on here and tell us how we don't know the difference.
Dan
QUOTE (Souless+Nov 12 2005, 05:41 PM)
dan my friend..u are a asshat.....lol

how bout we put you behind us..lol and forget u even posted smile.gif lol.gif
OK. laugh.gif
Souless
i was only funnin arround..... smile.gif (obviously)



and yeah i think there is prob bout 2000000 threads on this issue...lol
Vile Suffering
you wont hear a chorus of gay ass keyboards and harps and gay shit in most any self respecting death metal song.lol

their you have it. Death metal is simply brutal and for the most part has indepherable vokills. Black uses synthes and all tht gay atmospheric shit and has more of a shriek vocal approach.
pestilence11
hi vile suffering i agree with ya there most black metal is pussy try hard shit but as for me i like heaps of metal...i think marduk are the best black metal band there is today even tho they mostly sing about satin and shit but being a singer my self i find singing thier songs is most enjoyable to sing along to ant thier muzik is not to bad to listen to but thats just my opinion...i dont really care if they put make up on and all that shit its the muzik that i care about i think there not to bad....
Webster-Wanna-be
I agree with Dave, Black Metal = Shit. Death Metal = Cannibal Corpse Gods.
Vile Suffering
Ive heard emperor and mayhem they both suck
Epidemic_Madness
haha but its true though black metal sucks balls comparing to detah metal
Ankan
Death metal pisses all over black metal. Most black is gay, but there are a few very good bands: Lord Belial and Dawn is my favourites. 1349 is pretty good too, but I don't really think they have a technical approach, they're just faster than most black bands. And their production SUCKS.

There's not many skilled musicians in black, most of them can't play for shit. To play black metal is like playing punk, just faster. You can be in a touring black metal band after playing guitar for one year. That's the biggest difference between black and death, the musicianship. Many of the best musicians in the world plays death metal, while I can't think of a single skilled black metaller, except Frost of Satyricon and 1349, and Hellhammer of Mayhem, Covenant, Winds, Thorns.
MorbidRedneck
QUOTE (Souless+Nov 12 2005, 04:40 PM)
glen benton said even way way way back in the day he always considered themself more black then death metal but for sum reason to the majority they are considered death metal.

...i mean play a cradle of filth song or sum shit then listen to a death metal song...i.e suffocation/cannibal and u will hear the difference.

you wont hear a chorus of gay ass keyboards and harps and gay shit in most any self respecting death metal song.lol
cradle of filth isnt black metal, there goth, which belive it or not is different lol...nut u wanna hear good black metal, thats not typical listen to Marduk.
pestilence11
QUOTE (MorbidRedneck+Nov 14 2005, 04:51 PM)
QUOTE (Souless+Nov 12 2005, 04:40 PM)
glen benton said even way way way back in the day he always considered themself more black then death metal but for sum reason to the majority they are considered death metal.

...i mean play a cradle of filth song or sum shit then listen to a death metal song...i.e suffocation/cannibal and u will hear the difference. 

you wont hear a chorus of gay ass keyboards and harps and gay shit in most any self respecting death metal song.lol

cradle of filth isnt black metal, there goth, which belive it or not is different lol...nut u wanna hear good black metal, thats not typical listen to Marduk.
RIGHT ON MORBID WELL SED!!!!!!

user posted image Now Playing: DARKNESS IT SHALL BE...MARDUK
Souless
QUOTE (MorbidRedneck+Nov 14 2005, 04:51 PM)

cradle of filth isnt black metal
here is a snippit of an interview with gian pyres i ran across...so if that dont say they consider themself black metal..lol



"Some people would claim you're pretentious and pompous; would you agree?

I think we're pretentious and pompous. That's the problem with black metal. The thing is that we have very black humour and certain things are said tongue-in-cheek just to annoy the Christians or the other metal bands. You need to use your brain and decide what we say is serious and what is not."


Mutilated1
Black Metal = wear black leather costumes, corpsepaint makeup, and change your name so that it sounds like a character in a Harry Potter movie

Death Metal = wear the same clothes you always wear like a band tshirt, no makeup, no silly name

Black Metal = sing about the cold, the north, the forrest, etc.. and incorporate as much gaitey as possible

Death Metal = sing about violence, murder, rape, brutality, rot and decay

Black Metal = sometimes play softly so that the keyboards and "melody" ( ha ha ha ) stand out

Death Metal = play as heavy and loud as possible at all times

Death Metal > Black Metal
BitterSweet
ummmm ok that made alot of sense to me blink.gif
corpse213
death is the way to go!
To quit out of "lo-fi" mode and return to the regular forums, please click here.