I have to say... I don't really know, but I think I may go with Mechanix.

well , back in the day , the four horesmen . But if both bands were to play their versions live today , the hat would go off to megadeths version .

Mustaine's Mechanix with Megadeth always seemed like the only real McCoy to me...

early metallica cannot be fucked with

sure it can , hear em play it now ?

Mustaine pretty much wrote it though. And technically he was in early metallica, so how is that fucking with them? But, yeah they probably can't play it worth a toot nowadays.

Four Horsemen all the time.


But of course - Ride the Lightning still pwns all.

I am a very big fan of both Bands but I'd have to say 'Mechanix' Both songs are fucking Great though.

cool stuff. this thread livvvvvvesssss.....

early Metallica songs where written by Dave from Megadeth so it's hard to say shit about early Megadeth & Metallica..

The Four Horsemen wins.

Motorbreath kills both of them IMO


But that's sort of irrelevant...

yup, seeing as that's not one of the choices.

I mean, like, DOI!

Well, yeah, but I thought I'd just throw that out there

If U hear them both they are the same song just didn't speed Megadeth's is faster...

The Four Horsemen

Metallica's version has more crunch, guitar-wise.